Internship offer with prior misdemeanor that was expunged
I’ve been reading other posts about this but wanted to get some opinions on how to handle my situation.
Long story short- when I was 18, I made a very stupid decision. I was dorming in college and found that the dorm room next to mine was empty. I was able to get in using an electronic key and treated it like a hangout space. One day, I thought it would be funny to move a piece of furniture from that room into my own.
The school found out, and I was arrested. I went to court, and the judge closed the case on the condition that I complete community service. After completing everything required, the case was dismissed and later expunged. I moved on with my life.
Fast forward 8 years- I’ve turned things around and returned to school. I currently have an investment banking internship lined up at a BB this summer.
I never really thought about FINRA fingerprinting or that expunged records could still potentially show up in regulated background checks. After doing some research, it looks like FINRA background checks may be more thorough than standard third-party checks.
Before realizing this, I filled out a pre-hire compliance form through the bank’s portal. The form asked about prior criminal history. I quickly went through it and clicked “No” to all questions. After submitting, I went back and carefully read the wording, and one question specifically mentioned being “charged with… wrongful taking of property.”
I am now worried because I was charged, even though I wasm't convicted and I can't edit the form after submission.
I have already ordered my FBI identity summary to see exactly what will show up on my record. I also plan to talk to my lawyer about how expungement is treated in background checks.
I’m trying to figure out the best course of action.
I was considering:
- Reaching out immediately and saying I made a mistake and need to update my form
- Waiting to receive my FBI report first, then deciding how to proceed
- Waiting for the background check process to reveal it and then addressing it if asked
I am in no way trying to hide the truth - I just want to say what has to be said and leave it behind me.
Any advice from people who have dealt with FINRA compliance or similar situations would be appreciated.
This is a pretty wild and anxiety inducing situation, bumping for visibility
Bumping good luck bro
good luck man
ur going to be fine. finra stat disqual is only for felonies & securities-related misdemeanors.
fbi bgc is usually instant -- like literally the second you leave the post office instant. have u gotten a chance to see what came up on it ?
Yea I got it back - came back with no prior arrests. Clean record! I feel much much better - I am def in the clear and can put this behind me. Thank you for helping me chill out on this lol
i know how it feels man hahaha. i remember fbi'ing myself after my expungement was official and it was nice to see
Been there, my friend (albeit a different silly mistake). At the end of the day there may be some paperwork and some annoying emails, but you will be fine – full stop. As long as you did not commit a felony or a securities-related misdemeanor, you will be fine. Take a deep breath. I know the haze you are feeling, trust me.
I had a non-financial-related misdemeanor that was later expunged via community service. I was 100% fine despite submitting this to my bank. I disclosed mine because my bank is much more stringent. They require you to submit any and all misdemeanors, even if they are not related to financial crimes, so I submitted mine for avoidance of doubt.
In fact, funny enough, to show you how unimportant this is
---> the only reason I had a headache with my bank is because they could not find a record of it lmao
I had to go to the courthouse and get records of the expungement because they could not locate the case.
Point being you are fine. Just read the fine print and make sure you are covered. Deadass use ChatGPT to see the fine print on language reqs.
why did u disclose if it got expunged just curious
lol just guessing this is GS
Congrats on UBS
Nah unironically this time 😂😂😂 this background check is deep as fuck
Bumping. Good luck man
Chiming in because I had something of a penchant for minor misdemeanors during my undergrad years… you’re going to be fine.
If it makes you feel any better, one night I was absolutely ramshackled and somehow managed to swap wallets with a buddy who ended up leaving the bars before I did. On my way out, a cop stopped me and asked for my ID. While I didn’t whip out a fake, I pulled out another dude’s actual ID… though good chance I tried to argue that it was me, not sure.
Long story short, I ended up with a fraudulent identification charge that got expunged right at the buzzer while I was recruiting for finance roles. THAT could have been in the scope of what FINRA is typically sniffing around for... You’re good.
You already took the correct first step in checking with a lawyer about expungement and background checks.
I didn't know an "FBI identity summary" was even a thing but pretty cool if you're able to basically have them tell you everything they see. How long does that take? Asking for a friend.
Between that FBI doc and your lawyer's input on background checks, I'd hope you can have an answer soon that this past incident is unlikely to show up. And if that's the case, then obviously say nothing.
If OTOH you get vague answers or some meaningful chance it shows up, then that's a closer call. It comes down to 2 factors: (i) how recently did you fill out the compliance form and (ii) how likely is it to show up. If you filled it out yesterday and it's super likely to show up, then Option 1. But if you filled it out a while ago and showing up on the background check is more of a tossup, then I'd go Option 3.
Feel bad for you bro. Insane how 20x repeat violent offenders get to roam around but you get in trouble with the law for a textbook university prank.
How do you even get arrested for this haha. Seems like you could’ve just given the furniture back. My sense is there may also be someone on the other side of the argument who is just not a chiller at all and made it a much bigger deal than it needed to be lol
Ur fine was in same boat
I was charged with misdemeanor assault when I was 18 (bar fight) and had it "sealed due to youthful adjudication" in the state of New York. I have answered "no" to all of those questions for interview/hiring processes for 3 different banks and never had anything come back whatsoever.
Absolutely do not reach out to them about this. I am 99% sure you will be fine given "expunged" is a complete destruction of the record whereas "sealed" merely hides it from public view. Said differently, your odds are even better than mine were and I had zero issues.
Sunt minima repellendus rerum deleniti esse. Qui iure sapiente delectus deleniti illo quisquam sed. Neque et harum ex nisi tempore sed. Unde quisquam sunt tempora et nostrum consequuntur ratione. Ad quis est itaque odit explicabo dolorem corrupti iusto. Hic id alias non quidem dignissimos hic fuga.
Et et ex atque saepe eaque unde mollitia sint. Dolorum animi doloribus fugit quos dolore necessitatibus velit.
Quisquam eum eveniet amet consectetur. Dolor in sed repudiandae aliquid ratione doloremque. Voluptatem eum impedit molestiae doloremque.
Necessitatibus et occaecati et quod sint delectus. Sed minus doloribus dolor enim aut. Ipsum minima dignissimos perspiciatis est ut et. Consequatur excepturi accusamus ex ipsam eligendi.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...