It's 2am and my DCF model won't work
Need to redo the DCF calculations done by an equity-research guy. Can't figure out how he's getting change in NWC.
According to his report in 2005, 2006
Assets:
Cash =161.8, 172.2
Restricted Cash = 13.9, 14.2
Accounts Receivable = 39.2. 42.2
Inventories = 0.2, 0.3
Deferred taxes = 17.1, 18.0
Prepaid Expenses & Other Current Assets = 10, 12.3
Total Current Assets = $242.3, 259.3
Liabilities
Current Portion of Revolving Loan = 50, 50
Accounts payable = 30.7, 32.3
Accrued Salaries, Wages & Benefits = 34.1, 35.9
Accrued Expenses = 34.5, 36.5
Prepaid Tuition = 14.7, 17.2
Deferred Tuition Revenue = 22.8, 25.1
Current Liabilities = 186.7, 197.1
He's got 2.3 for his change in NWC. Anyone know his this was calculated? Thanks!
(-) Change in acct rec. = 3.0 (-) Change in inv = 0.1 (+) Change in acct pay = 1.6 (+) Change in accrued salaries = 1.8 (+) Change in accrued expenses = 2.0 Net change in WC = 2.3
hope you got this on time mate
Maybe I work for "jefferies" too, but prepaids are normally considering working capital in my book. The only things that are definite exclusions are obviously current maturities (add back to long-term debt), cash, and possibly deferred taxes
mates thank you all for the help. Just echoing what Solaxun said, can anyone explain the rationale for excluding deferred taxes and prepaid expenses in the NWC calculation?
Cuz they don't reflect on cash changes relevant to operations in the current accounting period, rather past/future periods.
So why is it that we don't consider deferred taxes?
Is it because it's tax (which isn't directly part of operations) or is it because it's deferred (which doesn't reflect the current accounting period)?
Generally speaking, we don't include deferred taxes in our working capital calculation. It doesn't reflect on the company's operations. It will still be used in the calculation of cash flow from operations, but it will be separate from the WC calculation.
It's essentially showing the difference between GAAP and IRS taxes (taxes payable vs. actual cash taxes paid), which is what pulls it out of WC.
I can agree with the removal of deferred taxes, since they eventually should not impact cash flows, but i still think prepaids are typically included in working capital calcs as "other ca" or "other cl" in most models, no? Also the deferral of tuition is probably included.
what a bunch of lifeless geeks..sorry but its true
We generally include prepaids in WC calculations.
Batemenan is probably a year 1 at a fund of funds, maybe mad because his MD yelled at him one too many times for not being a "lifeless geek" and constantly !@#$%!@ up.
1) Prepaids are included in WC Calculations along with Deferred Revs 2) The prepaid is +2.3 but the deferred tuition rev is -2.3 ...
To clarify
(-) Change in acct rec. = 3.0 (-) Change in inv = 0.1 (-) Change in prepaid = 2.3 (+) Change in acct pay = 1.6 (+) Change in accrued salaries = 1.8 (+) Change in accrued expenses = 2.0 (+) Change in deferred rev = 2.3
-3.0 - 0.1 - 2.3 + 1.6 + 1.8 + 2.0 + 2.3 = 2.3
You left out prepaid tuition in the CL section of 2.5 which results in a net change of 4.8, not 2.3.
sorry, could someone explain fully why deferred tax (both assets and liabilities) shouldn't be included in working capital? it does impact your cash flow (if your deferred tax assets go up, you've paid more taxes in cash than you've recorded). thanks for any insights.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't deferred tax assets and liabilities both non-cash items. Also, doesn't deferred tax assets/liabilities arise from a timing difference between what you report to the gov't and to shareholders - so it isn't actually a cash inflow or outflow?
See this : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_capital
I've heard of many reasons why deferred taxes are left out
1) It's not always taxes deriving from operations and distorts the picture (usually coming from depreciation / capex) 2) Deferred taxes are not always "current" - so they're not part of current asset or current liability - this is true for lots of retailers
Hey op - how is deferred tuition revenue different from prepaid tuition? ...
I assume deferred tuition revenue is revenue that you've been paid but services have not been rendered? ... same as prepaid tuition
If deferred tuition revenue is just revenue you HAVE NOT been paid but services rendered ... that's just accounts receiveable and is an asset?
In my experiences, you exclude DTaxes since they're related to accounting treatments not management's direct decisions on managing operational cash sources... you do include the variation in DTL / DTA but you do that in the cash flow statement after the working capital line, this affects you cashflow but does not distort management's ability to extract cash by more closley managing operations and financials...
Im a EU student and I can't swear that this applies for US GAAP (although I think so). Deferred taxes shouldnt be included in WC because it refers only to the group; not the legal entities. That should imply that deferred tax liabilities normally arise as a result of taxable difference in the value of assets in the group and the legal entity. For example, intangible assets that only arise from acquisition (say, brands). As for deferred tax assets, they can arise either from book values in group being lower than in the legal entities, resulting in a tax deductible diffference, or as a result of a loss in one of the legal entities and hence a loss-carry-forward. Since neither of these actually affect paid tax, they should not be included in WC.
Hope this contributes.
Solaxun,
"You left out prepaid tuition in the CL section of 2.5 which results in a net change of 4.8, not 2.3."
I actually think the answer is in what i mentioned about why defered tuition revenue and prepaid tuition are 2 separate entries - 1 of those is a non-cash item as in i think deferred tuition revenue is just like customer deposits and don't count as a change in WC
that's why its not included in final calculation
The company is Devry. From their 10K, deferred tuition is: "DeVry University and Chamberlain College of Nursing students who receive employer tuition assistance may choose from several deferred tuition payment plans. Students eligible for tuition reimbursement plans may have their tuition billed directly to their employers or payment deferred until after the end of the session."
So I'm confused ...
from an accounting point of view ... deferred revenue here should be the same concept as prepaid tuition ...
Prepaid tuition = money already collected, service not yet rendered. Deferred revenue = service currently being provided, money not yet collected. Am I right?
Right - if that's what it is .... then the service being provided money not collected ... thats same as accounts receiveable then and is an asset
clearly its being treated as a liability b/c the two are similar
sorry i dunno enough about this line of business but those are 2 two points that are contenitious (hence the difference in NWC)
You can just ask teh research analyst ...
On the other stuf, the prepaids, etc are pretty clear that tehy should be included
Doloremque voluptatem aut iure est fugit. Amet est velit ut et ipsum. Nam neque voluptatem eos eveniet. Et est id fuga omnis modi aut. Vel in totam voluptatibus fugit.
Aut distinctio perferendis aperiam. Consectetur et rem sunt exercitationem. Cupiditate voluptatem impedit modi quis et sunt.
Et voluptatem qui et. Itaque cum illo harum quasi voluptatem consequatur quisquam. Perspiciatis autem suscipit tempora facere magnam beatae. Ut sapiente quia est qui suscipit exercitationem. Aut a nihil aliquam nihil aliquid accusantium iure.
Debitis molestiae quia ab voluptas soluta quam. Et cum dolorem qui exercitationem ea quam et porro. Aut at rem commodi quae quidem. Et reprehenderit tenetur voluptatem aut. Sequi velit vitae enim numquam ut.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Nihil laborum necessitatibus asperiores vero enim. Autem non modi qui consequuntur quod sunt. Eaque qui placeat beatae pariatur.