Lincoln vs. Moelis NY vs. Baird
Deciding between these three. Thoughts? Looking for PE exit opps, B-School Placement, and Lifestyle/Comp. Have heard some shitty things about Moelis NY lately.
why is this even a comparison? you either don't have an offer at moellis or stupid enough to compare it against the other 2
Are the differences that big? I understand Moelis places better, but I have heard that the NY office isn't even close to the LA office.
So if the NY office marginally places better than the other two, and has a shittier lifestyle and culture since they grind their analysts, what's the point? Prestige is not playing into my decision at all.
when you're comparing a top boutique to lincoln/baird, middle market/lower middle market shopps, it shold definitely play a role.
Fair. So then what's the deal at Moelis NY? Anyone actually/directly know about placement, comp, lifestyle, etc.
On the topic of comp, top bucket for first years at Moelis was $80k this year. (A few points of comparison: Centerview ($85k), JPM ($65k), RBC ($55k)).
I read an article that said Moelis was going to make sure partners stay liquid so that they don't succumb to the exit pressures of going public 1, obviously that doesn't directly affect analysts, but it seems to play into this idea of having a reputation/culture that keeps pay sufficiently above-Street.
For what it's worth, I would go with Moelis. From what I've heard (not through WSO), the mixture of higher expected exit value (prestige), comp and frankly the potential access to higher-profile deals (Baird and Lincoln really don't get to work on the Publicis-Omnicom deals of the world) would be worth a pretty large differential in lifestyle in my book.
1 http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/07/11/big-paymout-by-moelis-may-whet-t…
Exit opps and placement are usually pretty closely correlated with "prestige".
Gonna go ahead and say Lincoln has the best culture, with really good B-school placement.
Seconded. Don't know about PE/HF placement but I'd imagine they do alright.
How do you have an offer from Baird? They have not even had their superday yet.
Moelis
Spoke with people from Lincoln, their culture seems real good. I probably wouldn't mind grinding two years there. Also, placement into b-school is pretty good at Lincoln.
Friend at Moelis says he wishes he would have taken the Lincoln offer. I heard there has been very lackluster exit ops over the last couple years.
Are you serious?
How do you think Lincoln's Los Angeles office is?
Why do you care? You ask about 10 banks daily on this forum.
Thanks for all the help, guys. Keep on hearing that Moelis is a complete sweatshop with overhyped exit opps so kind of leaning away from that.
Despite Moelis being a sweatshop, the exits are infinitely better than both Lincoln and Baird (even if they may be somewhat over-hyped). Baird and Lincoln are both regional players with OK exits (mostly also regionally, though can't speak for Lincoln NY office). And when I say OK exits I mean you aren't going to Madison Dearborn or GTCR
Love that you clarify that "OK" exits don't include GTCR and Madison Dearborn.
I think that he's implying that both of those are better than "OK"...
Definitely Moelis, not even close.
Are you guys seriously telling him to go Lincoln International? sometimes WSO has mind-bogglingly biased views of MM IB firms that while solid are not as good as their BB or top boutique counterparts. Moelis, by far - I've seen these guys go to every top PE shop (megafund, semi-megafund (apax, h&f etc.) top top MM PE (gtcr, mdp, etc) funds), top hedge funds, etc. and this isn't even including their stellar LA placement (which is pretty much all megafunds+silver lake).
At Lincoln the best analysts might get interviews with decent MM PE shops (maybe 1 every couple of yrs to gtcr and the like), but you won't see that level of placement. Just do a linkedin search, you'll see quite a few recent top placements from Moelis. Yes, from speaking with people there their lifestyle seems abysmal even for banking, but an extra 15-20 hours a week for 2 years won't kill you
As someone who has worked 2 yrs in banking and in PE now, please take some of the advice above with a grain of salt.
For someone who's "worked 2 yrs in banking and in PE now", you don't comprehend too well.
Those of us who commented about Lincoln were only referring to "B-school placement" and "lifestyle". If my math is correct, that's 2/3 of the criteria OP was looking for.
You only mentioned 1/3 of the criteria, and somehow made the generalization that "exit opps" are EVERYONE'S number one priority. News flash, cheif. Not everyone wants to go into PE. There is this thing called a "career banker" for those who enjoy the advisory business. I don't even think anyone on here actually said, "choose Lincoln", so not sure what you're bitchin' bout.
Autem sit ut vitae non odio. Omnis eligendi et at corporis facilis. Doloremque odio dolorem et et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Libero velit ut possimus temporibus et. Suscipit saepe qui quia magnam necessitatibus harum inventore. Similique ducimus eius et temporibus tempora et debitis. Et similique ducimus quae nihil molestiae ut soluta.
Accusantium vitae magnam aliquam sint et. A ex nulla officia animi repellat quibusdam. In quis recusandae rerum recusandae.
Rerum quis explicabo dignissimos. Aperiam quidem laudantium expedita minus laboriosam quas perspiciatis. Laborum voluptate libero cumque architecto quibusdam. Architecto esse odit itaque fugit dolor consequatur. Dolor quia et est est ipsum. Explicabo voluptatem asperiores minus rem.
Repellendus rem accusamus sed culpa. Facere nihil dolorem ipsum ipsum saepe culpa.