transgender working and recruiting for IB
hi there, i'm a trans (MTF) woman who's recruited for IB at a BB. for context: i fully pass (looks, voice, etc.), most people in my life simply believe i'm just a cisgender female, but my IDs still say male.
i was fortunate enough to be granted an offer at a BB and was wondering if there would be confusion regarding background checks / flagging and how to navigate that. i did not recruit via any female-only diversity initiatives so i'd imagine not (?) but would appreciate if anyone here could provide some insight.
i was also wondering how this would actually affect my internship experience. although i do pass, i'm worried that i'll be treated differently (negatively) during my SA if word somehow gets out (although i'd imagine HR does a fairly decent job at keeping things disclosed).
hahah, okay "analyst 1 in ib". i imagine you're working long miserable hours which makes it all the more funnier that you're spending your downtime commenting this
i think if i used the men's restroom it would be more creepy, since i am attracted to men, but i'd be more than happy to if that's what miserable analyst 1 in ib is asking of me x
Seek help if this isn't a ragebait. Your team will find out quicker than you deciding to take estrogen over therapy.
HR will love you and make sure that you get a return offer for sure. You are in the top decile in terms of candidate attractiveness nowadays, even if the emphasis on DEI has weakened a bit.
cool - what about answers to the actual questions of this post though?
Assuming this isn’t ragebait, I genuinely would recommend you look to work outside of high finance coming out of undergrad. This isn’t me trying to push you away from the industry because I have some sort of issue with trans folks (I have a close trans family member), but I’m telling you straight up to try to help: it is very unlikely you will be successful and have a career with any sort of longevity in this industry. If you just want to do IB for two years and get out, totally different story and it could make sense, but you will be treated very differently than a cisgender girl for your analyst stint (people will know). But a long term career with several promotions? I’m sorry, but it’s just not going to work, no matter how good you are at the job. Most people in this industry are going to classify you as having a mental illness, and people do not want someone with a mental illness managing their money or running deal processes. I’m very sorry if this hurts you, but it’s the general view in the industry.
.
Finance is a small industry. If word spreads, it spreads fast. Even if it doesn't, not everyone is built to handle fear and looking over their shoulder for a 20-year+ career. If you're adamant on going the IB route, I would be cautious and exit to a more welcoming industry i.e. tech/venture.
Comment you responded to may be correct but just do it anyway. Assuming that most people in the industry aren't complete idiots, I would expect them to have more nuanced views of trans folks after experiencing one themselves. Compared to your average college experience you'll likely meet more bigots, but nothing too crazy. Just keep your head down and get the job done. If MDs found actual monkeys that were able to do the job they wouldn't give a fuck about what genitalia they have. So just don't make a big deal out of it and keep it pushing. Good luck.
Ridiculous comment, this is NOT the general view in the industry
Disagree. I’d hire whoever can generate the most pnl and has the highest ceiling. I luckily only did 2 years of banking before leaving to buy side but disappointed nothing has seemingly changed in 15 years.
Analysts don't have shit to do with the P&L. They would need to be cranking out some pretty great Excel sheets and Powerpoints.
I disagree. Clients and coworkers might bring that assumption or bias into a meeting or your bullpen, but nothing that can’t be overcome with hard work, good tombstones / successful outcomes, a sharpened and honed instinct for sales, a professional image and a supportive attitude. You can definitely be the outlier and I wouldn’t let anyone discourage you (even if some commentors are being earnest and have your best interests in mind). See what happens and give it your best shot. Also, you may leave IB and go to the buyside, where projecting a certain image may matter less depending on the role.
this is the dumbest take on the whole thread, OP will be perfectly fine
Dumb take lol
Probably the same comment female bankers received 20/30 years ago
You are competing with a smaller pool of candidates at all career stages until it becomes a new normal
Would you say this commentary applies to (male) disabled (physical only) people as well?
Some weird hateful outbursts in the thread. I don’t necessarily agree with it but who the fuck cares, that’s not what you asked.
The answer is to disclose only to HR that you are transgender for context when you provide your background information. Maybe have some copies of your birth certificate/government issued name change documentation in case it’s requested.
You’re not obligated to tell anyone on your team, but I would ask HR about navigating bathrooms specifically. Just want to get ahead someone complaining about your bathroom of choice with official company policy should it be an issue.
The reality is, banks are just starting to have gay internal social networks, but still I haven’t seen any explicitly/flamboyantly gay people in the office - this is to say expect to keep it conservative in your appearance and information you choose to share. Early in your career you may think to share all your personal life details with your junior peers in effort to make friends, but even if you weren’t trans, I’d advise you to just keep your cards to yourself - not everyone deserve to know your non-work lifestyle. Severance is not too far from reality.
I think you are in relatively uncharted territory, so just good luck I guess. Most bankers are conservative so I genuinely hope you don’t get iced out socially if people find out you’re trans, but just know it may happen. Oh well, get your 2 years of experience and you’ll figure it out.
.
If it gets out I imagine you will be socially alienated but I’m sure that is the story of your life. It is very commendable that you have the balls (pun intended) to enter an industry with retards like the ones replying to this thread. I can’t imagine anyone genuinely giving you a hard time, though. Leverage the HR benefits if you are comfortable with it. It might get out, it might not, but at the end of the day if you’re chill and easy going you will be liked by 90% of your coworkers. Outside of the office they might look at you a bit weird but I get the sense you are aware of this and won’t let that get to you. I personally think you will be completely fine. Congrats on the BB offer. I can appreciate how this might be nerve wracking for you and wish you all the best
hey, i appreciate the wishes and kind words :)
out of curiosity, what HR benefits are you referring to?
Was just talking about DEI programs for full time. If you want to start your career in banking and are scared about not getting a return I’m sure you’d be almost guaranteed a return if you disclosed to HR.
Not even the biggest supporter and I'm pretty neutral about a lot of this type of stuff but honestly pretty ridiculous and sad how people respond to posts like this. MS me all you want but this person went through the same process and clearly earned it. People gotta have more respect or at least the decency not to be a keyboard warrior and instead just move past the post if you don't approve.
People attacking it unprompted is because it is celebrated in our faces unprompted, constantly. It's like every day your alarm goes off you were required to hear a recorded apology to dogs for taming them.... Eventually you would fuckin hate hearing it all the time and dislike dogs as a sort of Pavlovian response.
all of your posts are about spewing negativity and hatred towards groups of people, it's honestly quite sad. feel free to reach out if you ever need anyone to talk to, i'm here for you :)
Honestly, the only thing successful people care about in this business is making money and if you’re efficient at what you do, pleasant to work with and a quick learner, you’ll do fine as a junior and if you are commercial and add value to your clients you’ll do fine as someone more senior.
If it comes out, I won’t pretend you will not be a curiosity for a little while but that too will pass and successful people in the business are too busy to care about your personal life so please get your numbers right and turn that CIM in time, thank you.
Anyone commenting negatively is unlikely to be successful anyway because letting prejudices get in the way of business is bad business.
this guy makes it rain
This is so comically stupid. I know plenty of MD level people that would absolutely want nothing to do with someone like OP on their team. Why put up with the circus it brings when you can find normal people to do the same job?
Focus on being really excellent at your job. If you’re good at your job and easy to work with, everyone will love you. Likewise, if you suck everyone will hate you.
Could not give less of a fuck whether someone is trans or not, just be good at your job and you’ll be accepted (hopefully)
Congrats on the offer ! Do not listen to the horrendous comments here. Maybe inform HR for administrative matters but it should be fine.
Don't let people stop you. I would not disclose given you cant control the bias of others but other than that go for it
Yea as others said HR at BBs will protect you but that's not the Q
If people find out they may treat you different that's the unfortunate truth. There's a variety of factors such as geography, firm, Group, etc that impact culture, that'll give you a varying response of "ok we don't care" to straight up harassment/discrimination - just like gender, race, etc
At the end of the day, work speaks for itself, if you're grinding and making your analysts life easier, they'll vouch for you and it'll quite people up.
HR can only protect so much when they are in a different floor, let alone a different building in many cases...
Or different city / district etc if that matters… I have head that sometimes they are even in a different country ;)
As someone within the TGNC community, there are definitely issues you will face as you grow in this career, but i disagree with other commenters stating you need to change career paths. As for the background check, I would jump on a zoom with HR to explain that you haven’t changed the gender marker on your ID ahead of it occurring. Some general points on working in this industry as a transgender person (or really any other minority who people have strong opinions on), at the junior level:
Besides all this, I will say that the best performers (firms or people) in this industry are laser focused on hiring skilled, hard workers. There will always be a place for them. I work in infrastructure and find my coworkers pleasant and very results-oriented.
If someone is openly transphobic (purposefully and repeatedly misgendering you, harassing you in regards to bathrooms, constantly inquiring in a negative way about your trans experience, etc.) avoid them to the extent possible. They will typically not change their mind and will actively make your life more difficult (whether through constant harassment or more insidious ways, like asking extremely difficult things of you to “prove” your worth).
Good luck!
Send pics and I'll tell you if you'll be alright or not
why u are a trans
You def don't pass lol.
Others have chimed in with helpful advice, specifically "Associate 2 in PE - LBOs" who said they're part of the TGNC community. I'd hope that you could actually connect with them in DMs as it would be beneficial to get more specific advice/they can help you navigate the experience.
Keep remembering to disregard the haters. If you succeed in IB and people find out you're trans, they'll just complain to themselves that you're a "diversity hire" or something, which isn't different from how black people in the industry deal with similar nonsense.
I just wanted to add that I think you're really badass. Not to "fetishize" your experience or anything but I think this is so god damn cool lol. People like you push the envelope and make the world a more interesting place to live in.
The guy below is just giving you a refreshing dose of reality (again assuming this isn’t troll, which I doubt).
If you truly pass as female and never tell anyone, you might do fine as people will just assume you’re a semi-attractive girl. If word gets out though, I unfortunately agree - it’s just too conservative an industry for someone not to try and get you out / hurt you, solely because you’re trans.
idk why people are assuming i'm trolling but i guess that explains the constant MS notifications i'm getting haha, i just want this thread to die now as i've received answers
No experience to share but I’m an incoming summer analyst (cis white male) as well and would not treat you any differently or even think twice about it. I have other friends with offers who I also know would not think twice about it. Can’t speak for everyone but, I imagine a lot of people our age would be pretty supportive.
Lot of 25 year old wanna-be rednecks on this thread seem like they’ve had a long day at work, maybe finish the Seamless and pack it up for the night
yea, i think i'm less worried about my intern class seeing as younger people tend to be more progressive / care less / will also probably be too overworked to care. was referring moreso to seniors at the firm
happy pride 🏳️🌈
contact HR, they're usually nice. look at your firm's lgbt resource group, try to connect with somebody in it. they're helpful in letting you know how much to "blend in". try to create some network in it, since they're usually close knit and would be willing to help you navigate a situation if needed (obviously don't bother them).
ignore the hate comments here. if consulting can have trans and non-binary managers and partners, i'm sure you'll be fine in IB. you might just have to deal with douchebags making comments like the ones here but it's unfortunately nothing new to our community.
as for your summer experience, i think you'll be fine if you're passing (if you're not, makeup is your best friend). try to connect with other summer analysts who're lgbt. other women who're from blue states/are non-religious should be fine to befriend too. i'm not trans, but i wouldn't tell people outside your firm's lgbt group you're trans immediately anyways. and even in the lgbt group events, people barely ask about your orientation/gender. you run the risk of attracting douchebags if you come out as trans to the non lgbt folks, and it's not necessary if you're passing tbh.
would not discuss any political topics regarding DEI and lgbt outside the lgbt group events.
some people on here have a hate boner for DEI because they called out once for using the f-slur in college and their snowflake ass couldn't handle it.
.
People in IB are prone to racist, sexist, and generally bigoted humor and hot takes and generally lack of professionalism. But no one will hold it against you as long as you are competent, easy to work with, have a good attitude (always be positive), responsive, and reliable.
People’s self interest in having subordinates who make their lives easier trump any bias they have - it’s a transactional culture and job.
That said, if you aren’t able to perform at that level people will hate and criticize literally everything about you. However, this also applies to cis straight white men - if you are not easy to work with people will find a way to condemn and criticize every single aspect of your existence. It’s a toxic, transactional, and unprofessional culture for everyone lol
None of this should stop you though - you just need to survive for 2 years to get the experience. If you go to PE, people will dislike you more because you didn’t grow up as a country club wasp than because you’re trans. If banking is unprofessionalism, PE is old money classism.
They already know.
congrats on vanderbilt MSF!
Although I have not personally worked with a trans person (either on the sell-side or buy-side), there was a guy at Credit Suisse who had Dwarfism that landed a great buy-side job at Harvard's endowment after his analyst years at CS (and HBS).
*Clearly not 1:1, but it help shows that - for all the lies people will tell on WSO - merit rules out in this industry (most of the time). The people who matter in this industry know this and will evaluate you based on your intelligence, grit, and execution. I use this as an example since I am sure that other CS analysts probably talked some shit behind his back - and you are likely to face the same thing. Roll with the punches and use that to create a chip on your shoulder to outwork those around you.
Again, not 1:1, but I have asperger's and sometimes the way I verbally communicate (largely pace of my speech) I can tell people don't like. Luckily (and after a lot of DD), I found a firm where this is not an issue and I am evaluated based on the quality of my research.
Delete
Delete
Honestly what a rabid bunch lurk in American finance and you can see them out on full display here. American society scares me. I’d suggest to move here to Europe eventually if you’d like to build your career in banking / finance - you will not face these issues here (or to a much lesser extent) because we are human here. All that should matter is how good you are at your job - no one should care about anything else.
haha this comment honestly shocks me - maybe i have an american-centric view but i've always believed europe to be more conservative if anything and america to be more meritocratic / progressive. albeit maybe things differ in the realm of finance
Look into it. Europe is the lone liberal beacon on this planet - although our values are being eroded.
No chance.
Optio corporis qui voluptatibus voluptatibus. Asperiores est vero dolor maiores qui dolores. Qui aut sed quas et. Deserunt corporis corrupti dicta qui suscipit eos.
Eligendi molestias nihil ducimus ut. Eligendi beatae autem officiis aperiam consectetur praesentium in. Ea tempore vel dolorem ea. Fugiat a voluptatem dolor ad ab est. Veniam aut facere incidunt harum sed placeat.
Inventore quis reprehenderit eos sit velit similique. Nulla ab cum architecto.
Voluptatem minima earum culpa tempore corrupti. Facere autem praesentium sit aspernatur et. Dolores ut ut delectus molestias repellat provident id.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Sint necessitatibus quasi dolorum amet distinctio veniam. Modi qui porro non nihil modi vitae ab vero. Cumque perferendis voluptatem voluptas iure. Sit labore esse dolores qui explicabo laborum iusto. Iure voluptas id optio architecto consequatur architecto itaque.
Tempora accusamus veniam unde. Quam at enim fugiat qui sit. Unde dignissimos ut esse perspiciatis.
Fugiat voluptatem quas ipsam rerum ut similique. Aut dicta odio ab cumque aperiam consequatur. Repudiandae reprehenderit commodi sit odit nihil nisi. Qui error vel temporibus.
Omnis id aut ea est. Assumenda facere maxime est sint reprehenderit quasi aperiam ipsum. Sit hic qui eveniet quisquam qui. Occaecati beatae quos aliquam veritatis.