How to Deal with the Biggest Weakness Question
Mod Notes (Andy): this was originally posted on 9/26/12
Interviewer: "So... what's your biggest weakness?"
To be honest, I think the biggest weakness question is one of the most bullshit questions you can get during an interview. But people keep asking it, so you’ve got to have a strategy. There are some shops/industries where the best strategy is truth. In most banking/PE interviews, not so much.
My favorite way to answer the biggest weakness question is to imagine the interviewer at their job and think about what they would relate to most strongly. Then I build an answer starting with, “I get impatient/frustrated when....”
You want to pick a problem that is endemic to the industry and essentially unsolvable. One of those things people just have to live with.
You want them to think, “Yeah, that frustrates me all the time too.” It sends the signal that you’re at least aware of the challenges, which puts you ahead of many candidates.
So say I’m talking to a VP. VPs spend their lives as the axis between senior bankers and analysts/associates. If they ask what my biggest weakness is, I might say, “I get a little impatient when things take longer than I think they should. That would be fine, except it turns out the timeline I have in my mind for something is usually pretty optimistic. This is something I’m aware of and working on. So ideally in the future all my expectations would be realistic and I would do a good job of communicating them to the senior guys so there are no surprises.”
Say I’m talking to an associate. Then it might be: “I get a little impatient when I need to teach people who are new to the game. Coaching’s important, and in order to build a strong team I know we need to get people up the curve quickly. In the past I’ve occasionally let coaching slide in order to hit a tight deadline, but in the future I know I need to make time to teach people how to do something rather than churn it out quickly myself.”
Say I’m talking to an analyst. “I get a little frustrated sometimes when managing multiple projects, each with separate deadlines, work flows, models, decks, and teams. Some people seem to be able to do it all in their head, but me, I’ve found I need a pretty strict system to keep everything on track. Let me tell you how I do it....”
Of course, this is what I say to myself in my head: "My biggest weakness is that I get really fucking impatient when fielding bullshit questions. Like this one. Next."
Perfect Way to Answer What is Your Greatest Weakness?
While there is no one right answer, there are definitely WRONG answers. For example, you don't want to touch on points that are critical to working in your profession. For example, you don’t want to say – I "don't like working with others" or "struggle with quantitative analysis."
You want your weakness to be qualitative and fairly easily fixable.
Let's be MECE about this. The weakness will be either internal or external/behavioral. Choosing a behavioral weakness shows a lack of self-control. People who can't control their behavior aren't even ready yet to start working on internal processes. So I advise you to go with internal.If you go with internal, it's going to be either cognitive (how your brain works, how you perceive) or emotional (how you feel). It's very hard to fix a cognitive weakness. (You can't cure stupidity.) Also, banking/PE have strong biases against people with cognitive weaknesses. So I advise you to go with emotional.
Within the realm of possible emotional weaknesses, only a few are banker-friendly. You need something endemic, mild, and productive. Frustration and impatience fit the bill.
Everyone in banking/PE is dealing with frustrations every day. (Anyone below VP who says otherwise is lying.) It's something everyone can relate to. So it's not off the wall to say that you've felt it in the past and that you're working on the perfect approach/response.
Perhaps you noticed that each example outlines the mitigation approach as well as the weakness? You would obviously never just say that your weakness is that you get frustrated, full stop.
You'd say, "I sometimes get a little frustrated when I face X difficult situation, and what I do to manage/mitigate that situation is Y." What you're showing there is that you have experience managing the tensions that arise during tough situations in banking.
I'd always go with a "compared to others" or a general weakness that we all share, such as public speaking or speaking one's mind which is a skill that is learnable. such skills/weaknesses can be evolved easily through work experience or extra curriculars. i mean through my time in the work place my ability to stand up, tell someonde they're (regardless of rank) wrong has increased dramatically.
Still need help figuring out a weakness - check out some examples below:
- Struggle with delegation
- Tendancy to spin your wheels without asking for help
- Often get lost in the details and forget the big picture
Also - CNBC shared a good guide with tips on how to answer this question.
You can read more about Investment Banking Interview Questions with our Comprehensive Guide on WSO.
Decided to Pursue a Wall Street Career? Learn How to Network like a Master.
Inside the WSO Finance networking guide, you'll get a comprehensive, all-inclusive roadmap for maximizing your networking efforts (and minimizing embarrassing blunders). This info-rich book is packed with 71 pages of detailed strategies to help you get the most of your networking, including cold emailing templates, questions to ask in interviews, and action steps for success in navigating the Wall Street networking process.
Beautiful memories from the good ol Office days. +1
personally, i feel "fustrated" is a bad word to use.
I have to agree with you there. To me that word makes it seem like you're letting whatever problem get to you
The point of this question is that you have to say something negative about yourself. It can be a weak negative, but it must be negative.
Let's be MECE about this. The weakness will be either internal or external/behavioral. Choosing a behavioral weakness shows a lack of self-control. People who can't control their behavior aren't even ready yet to start working on internal processes. So I advise you to go with internal.
If you go with internal, it's going to be either cognitive (how your brain works, how you perceive) or emotional (how you feel). It's very hard to fix a cognitive weakness. (You can't cure stupidity.) Also, banking/PE have strong biases against people with cognitive weaknesses. So I advise you to go with emotional.
Within the realm of possible emotional weaknesses, only a few are banker-friendly. You need something endemic, mild, and productive. Frustration and impatience fit the bill.
Everyone in banking/PE is dealing with frustrations every day. (Anyone below VP who says otherwise is lying.) It's something everyone can relate to. So it's not off the wall to say that you've felt it in the past and that you're working on the perfect approach/response.
Perhaps you noticed that each example outlines the mitigation approach as well as the weakness? You would obviously never just say that your weakness is that you get frustrated, full stop.
You'd say, "I sometimes get a little frustrated when I face X difficult situation, and what I do to manage/mitigate that situation is Y." What you're showing there is that you have experience managing the tensions that arise during tough situations in banking.
I personally would be much more worried about a candidate that has never felt severe frustration before. Those poor bastards start running around with deer-in-the-headlights stares about six weeks in.
good answer but i feel personal weakness is too weak. fustration is an emotion which is on the road (without sounding too Yoda) to anger etc.. Further, it can be read as a sensitivity along the lines of: "hey, my feelings are effected by others beyond my control [slight hiperbole]". Hence, i'd always go with a "compared to others" or a general weakness that we all share, such as public speaking or speaking one's mind which is a skill that is learnable. such skills/weaknesses can be evolved easily through work experience or extra curriculars. i mean through my time in the work place my ability to stand up, tell someone they're (regardless of rank) wrong has increased dramatically.
Thank you for breaking it down that way. It helps seeing it through the eyes of the interviewer, much appreciated.
Not quite on topic with your interview question, but I once interviewed at a valuation firm when I got out of the military and they asked a shitload of technical questions I didn't get and hadn't ever studied. This was back when "Friends" was still on TV or had been recently cancelled, and at one point in the interview, I told my interviewer I felt like Joey Triviani trying to answer the questions,
No idea why I said that, but the female director sitting across from me bore a freaking hole in my soul with the look she gave me. So that didn't go too well.
Probably because it's Tribbiani.
kryptonite.
Nice. If they are going to throw you a softball... might as well hit a home run.
What would the interviewer do?
LOLzzz
how to answer the weaknesses question (Originally Posted: 09/25/2006)
any ideas?
I thought weakness is supposed to be a "skill-related" thing? Being frustrated is simply your feelings, not how capable you are at doing something.
e.g. Being frustrated at coaching new people is your feeling; unable to coach new people because I lack communication skills is a weakness. Obviously, I'm not gonna say I lack communication skills in an actual interview. Just an example.
and negate with I'm trying to learn by ......
Or just tell them a truth about some weakness which you can't see affecting the job too much and then tell them that you are trying to overcome this by..........
Hoope that helps.
yeah I think everyone who goes to interview is told to push off a strength as a witness, which gets old.
I know someone who got a job, because he was honest and told the interviewer that he wasn't a fan of Mondays. The recruiter told him that his honesty was refreshing.
I cracked a joke about why my best friend thinks I suck. The interviewers couldn't stop laughing for like three minutes. I got the offer. I guarantee you that recruiters get tired of hearing the same cliched answers to that and look for something extra to differentiate a 3.74 econ major with a minor in finance from a 3.70 econ major with a minor in finance
Nice, mind if we know what you ended up saying? Just to get an idea.
I’m a bit older than some of the junior mist makers on this board so I’ve gone through the recruiting process (nightmare) at a number of firms (IB/PE/other institutional investors) and while I think some of OP’s examples are good, they’re generally BS and most experienced interviewers will recognize that. Obviously you don’t want to say “I’m not detail oriented” or “I’m socially awkward” since analysts have to be attentive and no one wants to work 90+ hours with a weirdo.
I’ve fielded this question by saying an analysis as part of my MBA program evaluated students on a number of different personality traits and I ranked at the extreme low end for allocentrism (yes, it’s good to throw around MBA jargon at any chance). In other words, I tend to think others are motivated by the same things I am – profit, nice risk-adjusted return, etc – and I have to work extra hard at understanding others’ motivations. I try to address this by over-communicating, blah blah, and although I sometimes struggle with it, it’s a weakness that I’m aware of, blah blah.
Kid you not, most interviewers eat that sh*t up.
The Dreaded Weakness Question (Originally Posted: 07/09/2007)
It seems as though many people are flying through their interviews, and then are struck dumb and begin to stutter when asked "what is your weakness" What are some answers that you guys have used when interviewing for finance positions? What weaknesses have you been able to make sound convincing, while not negatively impacting your interview?
love this
My weakness is that I tried to multi-task too many varsity sports teams in middle school and didn't get into the most prestigious highschool in the bay area?
Although, I'm interning at RS funds in San fRan as we speak.
You want to make your weakness sound like a positive. For example, I said in an interview once that I occasionally become too involved in my school work/work in general and unfortunately have been known to neglect my family and friends on the eve of a test or big project, or when something needed done in the office.
haha that's exactly what they want and you know it.
You can be honest and describe a true weakness, too. Just don't tell them you can't work more than 5hrs/day or something dumb that will obviously hurt your chances.
Come on, I would have nearly laughed in your face had you said that to me in an interview. Thats so transparent.
I think the best way is to turn a weakness into a strength (but still giving a real weakness). So don't say anything like perfectionism. That's the worst answer possible. The second worst might be procrastination, which not only is too commonplace but also a red flag for finance jobs. And don't say anything completely irrelevant either (i.e. if you're addicted to something). Remember that you can always say how you've been working on improving in the weak area.
this is a good question
however
they're not stupid and they know we preprared to "lie" about this question then what if they reply "working too hard sounds like a strength to me, what other weakness?" (i heard one of my friend was in that situation) how are you going to respond?
This was a tough question for me to answer. Find something that you're working to improve. I was always really nervous during interviews, so I always mentioned that I spoke too quickly as one of my weaknesses. I followed that up with what I was doing to work on that (picked a part-time job that involved a lot of presentations and public speaking).
i work at a bb and the operations people are all pretty lazy and stupid. learning to work with them is a challenge.
I am a regular poster here, but i changed my name for this thread, because the answer I gave is pretty unique and people know about it. When asked my biggest weakness according to my best friend was, I said that "knowing my best friend, he would probably say confidence with girls". Instant hit. One of the interviewers laughed for good 3 mins, the other one laughed for like 30 sec and managed to continue the interview, but it was pretty obvious, that, after all other factors, this pretty much nailed it. I got the offer and accepted for a top BB
Damn, I would have hired you too.
My weakness is, I couldn't ever pull that off that answer with a straight face.
How is confidence with girls a weakness? Or are u saying that you're NOT confident around girls?
How do you recover from this in a second round interview?
"After a couple of remarks you made last time, I get the feeling that you're a bit arrogant..."
What I overheard from a good number of people who interview summer/FT candidates where I currently work is to answer your "weakness" question with a former weakness you are currently working to improve. Shows you take initiative to correct your problems while still being honest. Also I have noticed a good number of banks have been departing from the weakness question to the "Whats your biggest regret in college?". Be prepared for that.
Tell them that you're not particularly good with numbers, and that you often don't pay attention to detail.
While this won't go over particularly well for a prospective intern / analyst, you might just find yourself with an offer for an MD spot.
Have you guys ever had that "Tell me about a time you FAILED and how you dealt with it"?
I got called out for giving a weakness that was really a strength. The guy leaned forward, said "Bullshit, tell me a real weakness." I later found out it was more a test of how I handle myself under pressure than really caring about a weakness.
Chocolate!
You could point a weakness out and tell them how its no longer a weakness,and how you worked on it to improve yourself
I always wanted to just say Kryptonite with a dead serious tone. Then just say next question just to see what the interviewer's reaction would be.
Hillarious, I would try this if I wasnt black lol.
My ankle and my love for mexican food.
"My weakness is that I'm too generous."
.
make sure you tell them that you are working on your weakness whatever that might be.
After telling them your weakness is Kryptonite, wait a few seconds and then say your real weakness is not knowing when it is appropriate to crack a joke.
They'll love it.
i'm a terrible bowler
i thought it was the latter..? or that your confident, but should't be?
as a previous monkey posted, i usually say kryptonite, i have used that on all my engineering interviews and i got offers for most of them, i am curious if it would work in the finance world.
i'd be pretty careful with that one. it's not very funny.
I usually say that I have a hard time telling people what they are doing is wrong, so I usually just fix it myself, but it shouldn't be much of a problem in banking because there are so many intelligent people.
Or you could say...
I'm too good looking, and all the females in the office get distracted, so they can't focus on the task at hand. In other words, HR doesn't call people back as soon as they should.
What is your biggest weakness? (Originally Posted: 08/19/2007)
If you had to answer this honestly, without a canned/bullshit answer, what is REALLY your biggest weakness?
My weakness? I cannot work with incompetent/lazy people. Once they slack, I get frustrated, stress goes up, and I want to throw my keyboard at them.
Feel free guys. Let's admit our weaknesses, let it all out.
i have a similar weakness...
i have trouble working with individuals i dislike and/or dont respect.
Chocolate cake.
I have a big time sweet tooth.
I waste time on unnecessary things when they interest me instead of focusing on what I need to be doing. For example: I will waste 2 hours trying to make an excel macro that will format a sheet for me instead of spending 10 minutes and just formating it normally from the start.
However, if I try to say something like this in an interview, the interviewer will think I'm full of it.
Had the same issue with Excel a week back. Copy/Pasting is mind-numbing, but setting the Excel Macro was a puzzle waiting to be solved.
i guess my biggest is that I tell it like it is, and im a gossip. I get annoyed easily by people who are incompetent but let the world know that they suck.
im trying to do a better job of being more discreet with my comments.
Addicted to Meth
thirdallnighter, did you use that in your interview? How did it go? I heard those are the types of weaknesses they are NOT looking for (i.e. really a strength in disguise). A lot of people I know tried that one, and the interviewer just said, "That's BS. Give me a real one."
jaclee, it really is my biggest weakness. I used it once (for finance, not banking). Did not really go so well, perhaps because I wasn't entirely convincing.
I guess I should also mention I hold very high standards too?
It eventually leads a slippery slope where I hate my team. Ends up with me working badly in teams (I can't help that it's staffed with incompetence), which leads to me wanting to do the complete project by itself. This is not the first, not the last time it's happened. It's one of the reasons I want to enter more lucrative sectors, the fallacy? that there is less incompetence in banking/HFs/PE.
premature ejaculation
kryptonite and planets not powered by a yellow sun
I suppose it's a legit weakness too but I think over time it just became cliche. I guess everything is a good idea until everyone starts using it. It's like that whole perfectionist thing. But if that's your real weakness, then it is.
My weakness is that i cannot depend on people. Even while playing sports i feel like if i don't do everything on my own, no one will. I feel that if you need something done the right way, then do it urself!
My weakness is that I can't take shit from people, doesn't matter if it's an Associate or Head of the Group, you get cute with me and I'm giving it right back.
Of course, I didn't say this in the interviews, I went with the typical perfectionist banker bs....
smh at some people coming in here and giving interview answer bullshit. "I hold people to such a high standard, that I often do all the work myself."
GTFOOH with that shit.
My biggest weakness: Vagina.
Any other answer is suspect.
What's your biggest weakness? (Originally Posted: 10/09/2008)
If you say "I am a perfectionist" or "I try to take on too much responsibility and challenge myself to the fullest"...I'm pretty sure that's a 100% DING
What are some legit/creative answers to approach this BS question?
Once I said I'm pretty laid back, BC at the end of the day, whatever the fuck happens, I'm still breathing and shit's a-okay. Got the offer. (of course, this wasn't for IB)
@jr253 Nice: allocentrism
You need to realize some of the banks you're interviewing with likely have your psychological profile if you've already taken those "personality" type of tests. They are designed to gauge your level of cooperation, teamwork, ambitiousness, work-life balance, etc.
How do you stand out?
Good answer: I always look for the fool proof solution. Since there is no fool proof solution, you'll stand out as a perfectionist, someone who's always trying to better things up
I think this one can be viewed poorly, too. Perfectionists can get paralyzed when things aren't 'perfect'. Professionals in fast-paced environments (like banking and PE) where quick decisions often have to be made with incomplete information might view this characteristic negatively.
No one's perfect. Take a long hard look at yourself and think of something you could improve. I for example tended to be a bit stubborn when it came to asking for help with a project; I'd rather struggle with it on my own until I get it. That works in a slow paced environment but in trading/banking, not so. As a result, I've become much more open to accepting help when needed and that has definitly helped improve my efficiency and made me more knowledgable at the same time.
Sounds lame but are there really any answers to these questions that aren't? At least this one's true and not just something that is intended to please the interviewer. Of course you don't want to say something that is a complete turn off; try to think of something that isn't terrible but something you are actively working to improve upon.
I usually would say something like, "I'm a terrible singer" just to be funny, then I would actually talk about something I'm working on, like WxOnWallStreet said. You just need to think about what kinds of things are hard for you, then how you're dealing with it. The worst thing you could do on this question is come off fake.
for the advice. I usually like bkm's method and come off with a joke, and then think of something.
Would saying something along the lines of being "too ambitious" turn them off?
I'm pretty much interviewing for Ops/Finance ... but eventually want to move into S&T.
Sometimes I just work too hard, they'll love that
jk
It doesn't matter what you say, as long as it won't affect your job performance (i.e. don't say "I hate and suck at doing DCFs"). just say something muted but true and sound genuine about it and relay how your improving and how you can succeed despite this weakness. If you have to ask other people on a msg board what their weaknesses are so that you can reuse them in your interview, I guarantee that you won't sound geniune and I guarantee that you'll fail.
I think that it if you say something a little more meaningful/genuine like I get angry at times you'll be fine don't something cliched it'll make you look stupid and fake.
when i'm focused on something, i can loose track of everything around me, including the time. i am working on it by using my phone alarm to set time limits for things.
this one helped me get the job. it was honest in the sense that it really is a weakness, but it is fairly easy to fix with the alarm. i still actually do it to make sure i don't spend too much time on shit.
Weaknesses Question (Originally Posted: 10/22/2009)
When an interviewer asks you name the top 2-3 weaknesses that you have? What's best way to answer without autmatically dinging yourself from the process?
Any insights?
Do people still ask this question beyond entry level interviewing? Insane.
I still have no idea what's a good way to answer this one.
Just be honest and say how you are improving them and give examples of progress.
Don't be honest if it's a real weakness. I think this question is mostly a shit test to see if you will acceidentally give away a real weakness like "I don't get along well in groups" or something like that. Beleive it or not, people often fall into this trap and give the interviewer a reason to ding them.
It's also not good to give the cookie-cutter answers that are obvious BS, like "I work too hard" or "I have too much attention to detail." Try to give a relatively harmless weakness and say how you improved on it. Most importantly, try to answer this question and move on- don't give the interviewer a reason to question or probe further with your answer. Some possible answers:
-I used to not be so comfortable with public speaking but have improved through _____. -I get a little impatient when other people don't do their fair share of work. But have learned to do my work and communicate with others through ___.
You get the idea. Key takeaways: 1) Don't give a true weakness for the position. 2) Don't give a bullshit answer you read in the vault guide that everyone says. 3) Give a simple harmless answer and move on.
I think you can give a "real" weakness but not one that will cause them to question your ability to do the job or freak them out about you. I once had to answer true or false to a question about whether voices told me to hurt people for a high level job. Even if you were crazy, it's amazing that someone would answer that question with "true". Like Banker88 said, it's surprising the answers that come out of people's mouths.
Interviewers are looking to find out the following: 1. Do you have any self-awareness? If you say you have no weaknesses or being a perfectionist is your weakness, you have no self-awareness 2. have you had to work hard to overcome anything? you will hit walls guaranteed as a banker. have you struggled or failed at something and had to overcome it? This is why a "real" weakness can be a better answer as long as it's not too real 3. Do you know how to answer this totally predictable question?
How to answer, "What is your greatest weakness?"- http://bit.ly/jQLC1
Gotta Mentor www.GottaMentor.com Connect to the Advice & People You Need to Achieve Your Career Goals
"I get a little impatient when other people don't do their fair share of work" is actually overused and BS. They'll see through that one, as it's not too different from working too hard, perfectionist, etc. That kind of response was probably good when the first person to ever think of it used it. Public speaking would be an all right response if the job doesn't involve much public speaking. It also tends to be socially excusable since not many can claim to be great at it. In any case, try to make everything you say unique because everyone else is also looking for the "best way to answer" for weakness. Banker88 is right when he said it's good to show how you're working on your weakness, so this part must also be unique.
Agreed something small would be the way to go here. Most interviewers can read right through the bullshit.
I am asked this question all of the time, and every time I conduct an interview prep I ask this question and am always shocked by the answer I get. Everything from "banker killer" weaknesses, such as can't multitask, can't work in teams, have zero analytical ability, etc. On the other side of the spectrum, I get answers like "I work too hard," or "I love working too much - I love working 90 hours per week" - Bullshit! and if it's not, I'll still think it is as the interviewer.
So, that said, here is how I recommend answering this question:
Give a real weakness that isn't a "banker killer" weakness - in other words, give a real weakness, but one that doesn't show weakness in an area that is ESSENTIAL to be a good analyst - attention to detail, good teammate, etc.
After giving the weakness and expressing how it has been a weakness through, perhaps, a quick example illustrating the weakness, provide proof/real examples and steps taken towards remedying the weakness. You don't need to have completely eliminated the weakness, but you need to be able to show concrete steps taken and those you will continue to take to remedy the weakness.
And finally, if you can, provide an example of how you have begun to implement the remedies and have moved towards eliminating the issue.
Feel free to shoot me an email if you have any other questions.
IBanker www.BankonBanking.com [email protected] Interview Prep, Resume Revisions, News, Articles and More - Stop by Now!
What if you give a real weakness, even one that maybe important to banking, but you talk about how you've improved a lot? If that's not acceptable, then what kinds of answers are acceptable (i.e., what are examples of real weaknesses that won't ruin your chances)?
Greatest weakness (Originally Posted: 03/20/2010)
Hey guys
just wanted to ask... How do you guys usually answer the question "what is your greatest weakness" without shooting yourself in the foot?
@ relinquis
Ha, yes, I’ve been asked it for more recent opportunities even though I’m more experienced….most acknowledge that it’s a pretty stupid question for someone with a few years experience but they like hearing what people have to say.
Say something along the lines of "Getting lost in the details." It is a real weakness, but not a deal breaker. You can substantiate it with perhaps a story from a past internship showing how focusing too much on the small details that were not relevant to the overall project hindered your performance. Then discuss how you are improving. Getting lost in the details is at minimum semi-relevant to banking and your interviewer will be happy to see you at least recognize a real weakness.
Just don't say, "I work too hard" "I try too hard" "I take on too many tasks/extracurriculars" or "I got an A- instead of an A in a class"...those are all very poor choices.
Why is it bad to say that you pile too much on your plate if its true, you can show that its true, and you can spin it into a positive for the firm?
I don't think taking on too many tasks is a weakness, if you say "I take on too many things in my personal life to handle my work life" that may be a deal breaker. I know that is a legit weakness of mine, and I've said it at just about every interview I've ever had and haven't had a problem with it. Saying "Sometimes I spread myself too thin, and often get so bogged down in everything I'm doing my social/personal life suffers" isn't a bad way to put it. I agree that the rest of those answers are BS though.
Tunnel vision is always a good one.
When I hear "I take on too many things" I can easily see how that would be a nightmare weakness for both a full time and summer analyst.
"Oh, I must have taken on too many things and I don't have it done yet, because I'm trying to only be a few hours late with all the other things I am working on. "
Good weaknesses:
I am impatient I worry too much about past failures I don't speak up enough
The only right way to answer this is to say the weakness and then give a specific example of something you are doing to address your weakness now.
Well, I take on too many things but I don't turn in stuff late. I may go with the "impatient" answer from now on. though. I don't worry about past failures, and I always speak up, so those won't work for me. Impatience can easily be spun into a positive for the firm.
essentially, your weakness must meet four criteria in order for you to "pass" this question:
1 your weakness musn't be something that will piss off your colleagues (e.g. "i sometimes have trouble turning my work in on time")
2 an upshot of our first criterion, your weakness should not be something that will cost the firm money (e.g. "i have a tendency to be absent-minded")
3 your weakness should be something you are steadily eliminating (e.g. "i used to take on too much work in group situations, but, after being elected president of _________ student group a year ago, i've learned to delegate much more effectively")
4 your weakness should be legit (e.g. "i sometimes get too hung up on the details of a project"), not self-serving bullshit (e.g. " i'm a workaholic")
With a question like this, try to state the obvious (but not in an insulting tone of course.) If it's something that the interviewer can see is a potential weakness of yours, despite giving him/her your best first impression, then mention it! First, the interviewer can see that you're being honest. Second, you're not losing "points" by mentioning a new weakness that the interviewer might not have been aware of.
For example, let's say you don't have that much experience working in large teams and the interviewer sees that from your resume. State "I don't have a lot of experience working in large teams" (unless working in large teams is central to the success of the role you're interviewing for!)
i always say something along the lines of: I sometimes become a little impatient when I'm explaining something to someone and they either don't understand or don't agree with me. I sometimes forget that other people think differently and have different views, so I expect them to understand at the same pace that I did if I am walking them through a problem and solution...or to agree with me on a viewpoint...since it makes sense to me.
probably not the best one out there...
What is your greatest weakness? (Originally Posted: 01/26/2011)
Since we're in the middle of a busy interviewing period, I wanted to re-post Wall Street Mentors' first Q&A with Scott Morris when he covers how to answer the popular interview question "What is your greatest weakness?"
If you want some extra interview practice and a candid critique from a Wall Street professional, Wall Street Mentors offers mock interviews.
We also offer personalized consultations, in which a Wall Street Mentor can provide you with interview prep and a strategy for best marketing yourself.
$199 seems a little above the price point of a lot of college students. I would absolutely use it if it were ~ $129. Perhaps you could experiment with the times (e.g. a 25 min interview and a 20 minute review).
Thanks for the note; we're actually currently offering mock interviews for only $99 (for limited time) for those that allow the recording to be used to build a subscriber-based mock interview Library. In addition, you will get access to this library for 1-year for free, while typically it will only be accessible through a monthly fee. You can e-mail me at WallStreetOasis.com>[email protected] for more details.
great insight from Chris- Thanks!!
I look forward to hearing more of your tips Chris. Thanks!
Smooth_Nico and Maverik,
Thanks for the feedback - glad you found the Q&A with Scott helpful. I'll be doing Q&As with Scott frequently, so please let me know if you have any career/job search or interview prep topics you would like me to cover with him.
Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Chris
Good interview with Scott, and I would definitely recommend reading "Polished."
Smooth_Nico and Maverik,
Thanks for the feedback. The next Q & A is in the works, and will be out soon.
Paranoia
Is there a Kindle format of the book in the works?
Would it impact me negatively if I answered this with "brunettes and 15 year old scotch?" Could show how well I would fit into the group and I've always been told that honesty is the best policy.
Chris,
I'm curios to hear your background. Have you done banking?
Thanks.
M&I also recently did an article on this.
i like it happy pants
My biggest weakness is that I like to sleep with CEO wives.
Interview guide - what is your biggest weakness (Originally Posted: 04/29/2012)
key points to one of toughest behavioral question - what are your biggest weaknesses video below:
great thread 'rells, next drink's on me.
I usually just say I'm a perfectionist. I get frustrated when I know the team could have done better..
bump
Just be honest bro
Does humour work?
Interviewer: So... What would you say is your biggest weakness?
Me: A combination of social awkwardness, arrogance and stupidity... Smiles
Interviewer (not amused): Thank your for taking the time to speak with us today. Good luck in your future endeavors.
Self-Cerntered as Weakness (Originally Posted: 01/27/2013)
Interviewing in S&T, more trading side. I think that my biggest weakness is self-centeredness. A lot of times I really dont have problem working with in a team. But its just i live in my own bubble, and find my idea very important. On the contrary, i think this trait has helped me to be creative and focused. Should I say this, given i can talk about its upsides and make the downsides limited?
lol. yes.
Please mention this as your weakness. One less competitor for me. Don't forget to mention your disinterest in the markets.
Just heard it from someone who actually works in HR. Do not say anything like this or "I am a perfectionist" type of things. They hate answers like this and they can tell the made-up answers.
Maybe you can say something genuine and related to the work that you'll be doing and how you are working to improve it.
Are you fucking stupid?
Don't say that. Please.
Jesus, no. These are supposed to be minor or irrelevant weaknesses that you're working on improving. For me, I could say something like "I'm not a very good writer, so I've positioned my career towards those positions where writing isn't critical to the role. When writing is required I make sure to get someone to review my work before sending.". (or now I can just say I get someone else to write for me)
Whatever you do don't talk about sociopathic mental issues as a weakness haha. How about you tell your interviewer how you lack empathy and how that makes you a more efficient trader or something lol.
Your weakness is that you get so caught up in work you overwhelm yourself by taking on too much, and need good structure to teach you how to stay on track so you can do your best work for the company
Practice saying this
ANT said it best: grow up. Acting like a crazy person just makes them deep six you
I usually go with:
"Where do I start, really? I'm a 24 year old analyst with 6 months of banking experience because I was too lazy/unmotivated to figure out the whole finance recruiting thing while still in undergrad. My firm hasn't had much (any) deal flow since I joined the firm, so my experience with real world modeling and execution is relatively non existent. I spend a ton of my work day on WSO/Dealbreaker/ESPN/You name it and can be a cranky in the morning. Oh and I consider Guinness to be one of the major food groups and have an issue with nasty hangovers. What was the question again?"
Greatest Weakness Question Help (Originally Posted: 02/24/2013)
I'm trying to vocalize a good response to the greatest weakness question for upcoming superdays and wanted to see what everyone thought about this:
I think my greatest weakness is that I take my strengths for granite at times and under-prepare in areas I know am strong in or for activities that I think will be easy.
To be honest, I think this is one of my biggest weaknesses. Would the interviewers just think I'm arrogant or lazy if I said this though? I work very hard when I know something will be challenging but at the same time do under prepare for tests in classes I think are easy etc. Thoughts?
For granted.
Haha, just about to say that. OP, how about attention to detail? And to answer your question, no, I don't think that's a good answer. Be more clear and pinpoint something that you actually aren't good at. Taking your strengths for granted is a BS answer in my eyes, it's too vague and doesn't say anything about you.
OP should give up now
Spelling being an illustrative example? Or perhaps an over-reliance on Chrome's spell-check function?
My go to for that is that I'm hesitant to ask for help. Its a genuine weakness while still highlighting a good quality, i.e. usually try to work out things on your own without heckling others all the time.
My Legitimate Weakness (Originally Posted: 07/25/2013)
So during my current internship, I have noticed I am not the strongest writer. At least in financial writing terms. As an SA here, I have had to write several research reports on several industries explaining growth drivers, risks, current multiples and trading levels etc. My MD has legit shat on my face like 2 times because I use "non-formal" words sometimes which makes my writing sound elementary. Sometimes I tend to jumble things up and my fast train of thought gets transcribed on the paper, unfortunately. Needless to say, a career in ER wont be happening..
Is this a legitimate weakness that I can bring up in interviews, or is this a terrible thing to bring up? I am not sure how much writing is needed in the financial world, so maybe someone can help clarify this. I don't want to say I am bad at writing if this is something that is essential for every analyst.
I've asked a number of people, "What are you good at?". You would be surprised at how few people answer that well for such a softball question.
That's a very good question that I've never thought to ask. Think I'll steal it.
That would be a terrible thing to bring up in interviews.
I believe in making a weakness into a strength with practice, practice, practice.
TradesaLot is correct. A question that is more often asked than the weaknesses one is "Why should we hire you". It pops out much often.
How would you answer that ? Especially knowing there are dozens, if not hundreds, of jacks you're up against.
I think you misunderstood... I obviously wouldn't "bring this up" in interviews. If they ask me to tell them about one of my weaknesses (which they will), is this a bad response? Because in essence, it really is a weakness of mine. And of course, I would do what you said and spin that to say I have been practicing and I am improving etc.
I wouldn't mention that bad writing as a weakness in banking interviews. Have you not worked on slides where you need to write up some mitigators for potential weaknesses of the client? Guess what that is?
Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that writing definitely also factors into the 'sales' part of IBD.
I think it depends on what else you want to do. If you go into sales or quant analytics, it would probably be fine. Unfortunately, many jobs require decent writing skills, but luckily, not that many require outstanding writing skills, so I would try to narrow it to something like, "while I can certainly write brief descriptions for emails, powerpoints, and business memos, I'm no Shakespeare"
My writing style sucks and I've survived plenty of time without being a highly proficient writer. (of course, now I have people write stuff for me, if I need something written).
Very true. Thank you for these points, I think that is a viable alternative.
What I've discovered as an SA in ER when writing reports is that theres a fairly good chance that, unless it's an initiation report, there is a similar report in the shared files that you can literally just use as a blueprint for how to write yours.
Best Practices for Equity Research Analysts is a good read for that sort of thing, too.
My legitimate weakness is that I don't take criticism well. Definitely not bringing that up, lol.
For weakness question just bring up something thats not relevant to the job at hand.
What if you truly are an elitist? Can you spin that around as being a man of high standards and selectivity?
Actually, I don't take this question too seriously. As an answer, I recently said that my orientation skills were bad, especially since Apple released its Maps app. The guy laughed. I'm waiting for his answer now.. I think they just want to see how spontaneous and unique you are
bankerella is the man. hands down. regardless, I wasn't offered a consulting position i interviewed for, and after I asked for feedback, she said, "I have someone who can bring experience to the table immediately, I don't think you'd have trouble, but it's valuable to have it immediately. your skills da da da da bullshit"
During the interview, I let her know my weakness was a lack of experience, being a new college graduate. I thought it was a bit crafty, but ultimately I was dinged. She was also very amazonian. That is all.
subscribed
Greatest weakness ---> large breasted women
Just say "Generally I have trouble lying" Then outline why this interview question is the hardest for you to answer because the status quo is bullshit.
I've actually said variations of these answers before and they have never worked out for me. I once told an analyst that my biggest weakness was I used to have difficulty doing menial work, but overtime and through my last internships I had learned the importance of mindless tasks and understood how doing these tasks perfectly results in your superiors trusting you with more advanced tasks. I've also used the multi-tasking example. I actually got yelled at by the first analyst for my response. He was potentially just a dick, but I've learned to give responses that have very little to do with banking instead. Now I say I get too caught up with understanding every small detail and have trouble seeing the big picture.
I always respond "chocolate....or icecream"
It's a great icebreaker, the interviewer typically cracks up a little bit and then i give my pitch about my opportunity areas.
My answer is I suffer from intellectual insecurity, meaning I am always trying to learn more.
Not sure if this is something that would be passable, what do you guys think?
Remember in Pulp Fiction, how Uma Thurman's character asks "In a conversation, do you listen or wait to talk?" and Travolta goes "I wait to talk, but I'm trying to listen more."
That would be my answer.
I'd respect that answer.
Enough to stir my old-fashioned? (whatever that means...)
I feel angry when an old foreign looking associate bitch asking me questions other than "you want extra soy sauce with that?"
my biggest weaknesses? definitely bacon...
I don't even answer the question that was asked. I pick a weakness I used to have, then describe and quantify what I did to turn that weakness into a strength. It's an interview - I don't want to talk about my weaknesses; I want to talk about my strengths. It answers the real question, which is "Are you self-aware"? The logical successor to being self aware is acting on that self-awareness - i.e. improving yourself. That is what I want to be talking about.
Stellar point here. The question really is, "Are you self-aware?" I hadn't noticed that before. Thanks.
How I approach this question largely depends on the interviewer. If the connection is good, I might be a little emotional.
Seriously folks... do NOT answer this honestly. This isn't confession. This is a pitch to get them to hire you so you can get paid. Certainly don't get emotional. Give the "how I overcame a minor weakness in the past" spiel that a previous poster (808) had suggested.
Interviewer: What's your biggest weakness?
Me: I'm not self-aware. To be fair, I guess I'm aware of the fact that I'm not self-aware. So, maybe it's not as big of a weakness as I thought. It's been something I've been working on.
Nicely played.
I ignore the question and redirect toward what I'm working on improving.
It doesnt necessarily have to be a personality weakness - you can just repeat an obvious weakness of your resume, and then give explanations for it, making this a bonus explanation question.
i.e., "I have low GPA" ---> because I was working two jobs, etc "I have no internships" ---> I realized banking was for me late, wanted to explore other options, etc
If you can avoid making it about your personality, so much the better, because personality wise there is just no good answer...
Thunder and grass
biggest strength: rock and water
Disagree. When I ask this question, I'm not asking for a resume weakness and I won't accept a resume weakness as an answer. I've got their resume right in front of me and I can be the judge of that, after all.
A pansy-ass answer like "My biggest weakness is that I have no internships" is going to 1) irritate the interviewer and 2) make them ask it a second time.
I actually agree w bankerella on this. Not to beat a dead horse but I've been on both sides of the interview table. I definately don't want to hear some BS about how you have a low GPA, gap in resume, lack experience, etc....that sh*t is obvious and I'm interviewing you despite those "flaws". I 1.) don't want to hear a BS answer about a minor weakness and 2.) would write the candidate off immediately if he/she turned it into a joke.
Every firm, industry has its own culture, etc. so that sh*t may fly sometimes but I want an honest answer and second the self-awareness....I want to hear a real weakness and how you work to overcome that, etc.
To OP, I don't know if you're just starting your career so you may or may not have a ton of work-related experience to relate to the interview but college students should at least be self-aware from group work, etc....more experienced professionals can answer this w work experience. I would respect a professional w 20 years experience that actually answered this Q honestly.
Then again, I work for a RE investment firm....but even as a former banker and PE guy, I just want an honest answer. If a 22 year old answered "I work too hard" or "I'm a perfectionist" I would end the interview immediately. Bottom line is, it's a legit question and you have to give a legit answer.
I know this will make me sound like a "total NOOB" but the answer I usually went with is "I'm a perfectionist, and that does take out a large chunk of my time because I re-read all of the models and emails several times, to make sure an error didn't somehow slip in" but judging by your post, you actually do highlight a personal weakness. Do you think I'm going the wrong way about the answer?
wonder if it's possible to answer the question with a completely left field response and make them laugh to break up the bullshit a little bit; then answer it a bit more serious after they cease guffawing
See my prob with that is.. If the interviewer seems like a cool person sure, but if you get a geezer that evidently has no sense of humor that will fuck you.
I've had experiences on both ends of this spectrum. Interviewed at a top BB (GS/MS) a few years back and met with two mid level guys that were a blast, having fun and laughing all around. The third guy stepped in and asked for a weakness so I hit him with a joke. He proceeded to bend me over the table and have his way with me (verbally).
I usually go with a solid answer that is a real weakness but an understandable one. For instance in that same interview with some other people (before the laughing commenced) I answered that "at my prior job, one of my biggest strengths became a weakness that I had to alter. I usually set early deadlines for tasks so I have plenty of time to go over them before they're due. Suddenly I was trying to do this with a team of 5-7 people reporting to me however I was being unrealistic and inconsiderate of their other duties by expecting early deadlines to be met. It took a while but I was able to adjust this and am still improving with new situations, it just takes some understanding of what others' responsibilities are like."
Now that I interview a lot of others candidates, I prefer asking "Describe one time that you've failed". I find that this one more directly forces a real weakness out of the candidate instead of getting some BS answer about their "willingness to die for the cause" is somehow a weakness.
Serious question, whatever happened to bankerella?
During 'my story', I mention how multiple shoulder surgeries from football forced my to withdraw my enlistment from the military my senior year of HS. The only interview I was every asked this question I responded with "My shoulders". It got a few laughs and we moved on. If they don't laugh I'll quickly follow up with some actual response.
As has been pointed out up-thread the real reason people ask this question is to see if you are self-aware. The best way to respond to these is to talk about how you have overcome a previous weakness...e.g. over the past one of the areas that I have sought to improve in is X. In order to do this, I have done A,B,C.
As a hiring manager, despite the fact that it is an overused question, I do look to see how self-aware someone is and the way you answer this question tells me a lot about you, how you interact with others and your EQ. A variation on this question that I have used recently is "what did your most recent performance review say were your greatest areas for growth?" The best answers in my opinion are those in which the candidate is honest but at the same time the candidate tells me how they have sought to improve upon their development areas (let's face it, we all have something to improve on and I am generally not going to ding someone for telling me they need to work on something...unless they bring up something that is 100% critical to their ability to perform the job that I am hiring for). The worst answers are ones in which candidates try to BS me, don't talk about how they have tried to improve or can't articulate a true weakness (e.g. telling me something glaringly obvious like my GPA sucks).
I recently asked this question to a candidate and he basically responded by saying that in his last review he did not have any areas of development and that he was a top ranked analyst in terms of overall stack rank and comp and that he could provide references from his prior employer. This answer basically tells me that this guy is clueless, arrogant and has no self-awareness or EQ. This answer alone got him dinged...despite the fact that technically he was the best candidates. In my world you have to have the ability to do the technical work but if you don't have the soft skills you won't be successful. For example, this answered told me that this guy likely doesn't understand how he comes off to others and let's say he is trying to get buy in for an acquisition from our leadership team he is likely not going to be aware enough to maneuver internal politics without alienating people.
Sed qui beatae suscipit aliquid ipsa ab. Iure laboriosam debitis nemo omnis.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Iste rerum adipisci dolores et sit ipsam ut. Porro amet ad quam sint odit assumenda. Quam maiores optio accusantium itaque vel et. Quo unde enim dolor consequuntur.
Suscipit et temporibus autem sequi ut eum laborum. Possimus in est ut et ab iure accusantium. Illo assumenda id eveniet minus quasi minus assumenda. Dicta nesciunt nam beatae tempore.
Hic qui eaque quis eius mollitia. Qui facilis dolorem et quia rerum consectetur odit.
Voluptates cum aut iste aut. Voluptas aut recusandae ex. Quas necessitatibus velit aperiam adipisci quaerat doloribus sit. Possimus dolores voluptatem perspiciatis quia quia laudantium quia. Ratione vel similique quisquam repellat quas laboriosam aliquid animi.
Reiciendis officiis veritatis libero officiis ut sed velit. Ipsa natus et accusantium est. Labore eum qui ipsum quia non odio autem. Fuga voluptatum enim modi natus nemo veritatis eaque. Dolores tempora voluptatem quod. Placeat ex et nesciunt provident.
Non facere enim fugiat et ut quisquam est. Qui provident blanditiis ipsa. Tempora et nihil facere eum odit at. Minus omnis quia et explicabo.
Saepe aut ex et quaerat. Voluptatem non est ullam distinctio. Explicabo officiis voluptas architecto amet rerum. Ut enim aperiam quidem quidem.
Est aut amet ut modi provident. Maxime maxime eaque distinctio. Explicabo facere quaerat tenetur rerum consequuntur est impedit repellat. Dolorem et qui in odit. Aliquam cum dolores animi voluptas.
Suscipit repellat rem reiciendis necessitatibus eius facilis. Sed cupiditate illum sapiente deserunt earum et necessitatibus. Voluptate ullam omnis voluptatum eum est. Non corrupti aut consectetur tenetur soluta mollitia. Molestiae voluptatibus dolorem maxime. Nulla modi omnis sit id atque et.
Sed nulla voluptas delectus ex. Dolor dolorem dolor repellat labore minus in suscipit. Laboriosam cupiditate autem recusandae voluptatem quos consectetur aspernatur omnis. Amet et aut magni ullam provident distinctio aliquam. Dolor repudiandae eius rerum in aliquam unde aliquam. Rem qui aut qui facilis similique maxime. Ut quia aut id eum tenetur dolore aut.
Voluptas voluptatem autem recusandae eos aut harum quia ut. Modi qui architecto in id rem atque. Sit consequatur explicabo consequatur nisi reprehenderit quia mollitia. Facere est ut voluptate eligendi mollitia similique rerum. Quis alias quibusdam ipsum exercitationem id. Autem est cumque aut sequi non aut consectetur quis.
Dolor sit nihil consequuntur impedit. Sapiente ea nulla vero sunt eum est aut reprehenderit. Commodi pariatur exercitationem minima placeat incidunt quas. Temporibus maiores ut explicabo consectetur libero ut. Laudantium maxime odit fuga molestiae. Commodi deserunt saepe modi aperiam.
Dolorem et beatae voluptatem laudantium officia nesciunt. Ea officiis ea quibusdam iste a sapiente sunt. Explicabo fugiat non architecto aut et consequuntur. Libero pariatur cum nemo.
Quia corrupti dicta et aliquam quod non. Nesciunt deleniti sit voluptates quam unde. Alias facere ut fuga quia assumenda et.
Id officiis quasi repudiandae dolores autem et quae. Ea illum quaerat a nesciunt et inventore porro ut. Dolorum quia ducimus est et ut. Qui mollitia rerum voluptas neque. Voluptate rerum aut tenetur delectus. Omnis earum id et saepe perferendis animi et. Dolorem similique sit excepturi dicta libero.